Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

gresskar wrote

Are VPNs, Tor, I2P and/or Freenet censored or throttled?

4

d1esel OP wrote

Sup! VPNs are very carefully blocked recently. Tor has long been locking, but for its use we connect bridges. I2P is not blocked in any way, because it is technically impossible to block it.

4

chatrouge wrote

I have few

  1. Are the human rights really as bad as western news make it out to be?
  2. Are Russians (the people) as anti-LGBT as we are told on the west?
  3. Is there general fear for conscription/getting conscripted?
  4. Lastly, what is Putin's real approval from your experience? Are people as pro-Putin as we are told or is it just massively inflated?

Thank you

4

d1esel OP wrote (edited by a moderator )

Sup!

  1. No. Rather, not quite. Due to the harsh mentality, the police may be dangerous to exceed their powers. But if they see "easy prey", then you can expect anything.
  2. Maybe you heard, we introduced a law on the ban on propaganda of LGBT. The new generation is not against the LGBT movement, rather it doesn’t matter to them, or they are its participants themselves. And the older generation is almost always against.
  3. As I understand it, you had a call for war (I could be wrong because of a machine translation). Yes, it is clearly.
  4. Most Russian people play for Russia, but not for Putin. Thank you for your questions! I was glad to answer!
3

ManMan wrote

Cool, nice to hear that Russia has not blocked I2P, I expect that with just 100 or so malicious routers they would be able to get the IP's of most of the network to block them. I have a couple of questions too:

  1. Do you believe that Russia may have a revolution sometime soon with people fighting for better personal liberties and minimal government?
  2. Does Russian media victimize Russia and portray the rest of the world, primarily the USA to be aggressive to Russia to fuel a stronger national identity (not saying that the US is not aggressive to Russia. Hopefully that will change with Trump) and get Russians fighting for the motherland?
2

iduga wrote

Well I'm not the topic starter, but live in Russia as well and can try to answer from my perspective.

  1. I don't. Lot's of people are in favor of Putin and politics Russian government carries. It happens because of various reasons. Massive propaganda is one of them. Anything against the current political course is forbidden. Most of tv time is given to propaganda shows and news. I can't really say that there is majority in favor or against because everyone against has to stay silent and everyone in favor can scream as loud as they want. People with anti-war points can be prosecuted even for statements in private conversations or chats. And besides, revolutions are not organized or carried by masses. They are made with money and massive help from outside. I don't believe that any of these processes is happening right now in Russia.

  2. Yep, that's exactly what they do. News mostly contain of war success stories (if any), some dad jokes about Biden or other western politicians, some worst stories from US or any European country. Like some ridiculous woke story or shoplifting in LA or even fires. And there always will be some connection to military help to Ukraine. Not exactly fighting for the motherland, because there is no actual existential threat so far. Some Kursk land was occupied but it is not widely covered because it is an obvious military fail. Narrative is more like fighting for peace in Donbass and Lugansk against Ukrainian nazis and NATO mercenaries and NATO weapons which wants to surround and weaken Russia. So as it is a mixture of nonsense and some reasonable things (which do not justify the invasion obviously), but still makes it easier to flush the brains.

1

Saint_Cuthbert wrote

  1. What do Russians think of (anti-Ukraine war) Americans? That is, the people who want it to be quickly resolved so we can dig ourselves out of debt?
  2. How religious is Russia? And what do they think of the secular societies of the western nations?
  3. Is western literature and media heavily censored?
  4. My friend's mom was Russian, and she said that they had to forage for food when she was young. How applicable is that to the general (Soviet-era) Russian population? Was there a lot of scarcity?
  5. How is personal liberty there? Certain things that are guaranteed in the US Constitution, such as the 4th amendment (freedom from illegal search and seizure), the 2nd amendment (the right of the people to keep and bear arms), the 1st amendment (freedom of speech), aren't available there. Are those prohibitions nominal? Could someone "get away" with exercising any of those rights, or would it be certain to lead to penalties?

And yes, I know that I mostly echoed the guy below me.

2

iduga wrote

Hi.

  1. Russian propaganda picks one weird buy and will quote him over and over. Like Tucker Carlson or some ex-military. When talking about normal people, those who I know and are against the war, do not generalize the nation. They understand that from foreign perspective we all may look like orcs, but people who can think, will not generalize too. So to summarize, pro-war think that all Americans are enemies. Those who are against the war do not think of enemies, but rather just individuals.
  2. Not really in general. Muslim regions are more religious. Most of the people in cities are secular I believe.
  3. Well, I don't think that literature is censored by the origin per se. Mostly social networks: ex twitter, facebook, instagram, even linkedin. The reasoning was different: from demands to delete anti-russian posts to demands to move the servers to russian data centers. All of these demands were obviously ignored. There is weird situation with youtube though. It is not officially blocked, but rather slowed down to be totally unusable without ani-dpi measures or vpn. And officials regularly state that the slow down happened because of 'google cache servers degrading' whatever that means.
  4. 90's were tough for many people. My parents sent me to the country area with my grandma because it was possible to have a vegetable garden there. And neighbors had cows and chicken. It was not all the years so difficult for us, but some were. And we lived in Moscow. I'm sure it could be much worse in smaller cities.
  5. These things sound like a joke here nowadays. There were absolutely ridiculous cases. Like journalists were almost prosecuted for the banners which contained quotations from the constitution. And the case was about... extremism. And don't remember what was the penalty. Maybe it was just a fine but the idiocy of this case was astonishing. And it happened in 2013. Since then many things changed. People were prosecuted for a blue/yellow flower on a woman bag, for ani-war statements in a private conversation. Police can raid into the club looking for gays (yes, LGBT is admitted as extemist organization and :facepalm:), line up everyone and make them sing some pseudo-patriotic songs. The law works only one way. If you face against some military/police/agent, you are almost rightless. The power is the law now more that any time before. It is not a Mordor though. If you do not take part in any anti-war discussions, clubs, meeting, chats or whatever, you will be fine. You can walk, travel and live a normal life. You won't stopped, questioned or ensearched.
1

TheRevolutionary wrote

What do you think about raising Novgorod from the ashes of history and put an end to the Tsar tyranny once and for all? Do you think Russian citizens could in secret build the much needed institutions and powers while still under the yoke of the current mongol absolutist power structure? Maybe over i2p? It's clear that killing Putin won't be enough.

1

iduga wrote

Hi.

For reference there was not an absolute yoke. It can't be for centuries. Rulers or the territories (principalities) were trading and making agreements with mongols. Probably normal people had not the best days, because the render fall on their shoulders in the end. But no one asked their opinion. And the rulers started to create alliances against the mongols when the conditions became worse and worse and the Great Horde weakened.

And as I don't believe that revolutions are made by masses, there is no way something like this can happen in Russia now. Maybe there is some kind of conspiracy happening right now in the higher circles, but it will not change anything. Maybe even more delusioned FSB official will have the power.

I'm afraid all this is for decades. Until all the Putin's generation generals, FSB higher ranks and so on become weak or even die.

Maybe I am to too pessimistic though.

1

d1esel OP wrote

OP here. Lately another person has been answering for me here :)

1